Our reviews
How we score games
Every score is an editorial judgment of the game as reviewed. The number is a quick guide to our overall experience; the review and verdict explain the reasons behind it.
| Score | What it means |
|---|---|
| 9–10 | Exceptional. A standout experience with qualities that rise well above its shortcomings. |
| 8–8.9 | Excellent. Strongly recommended, with only limited issues holding it back. |
| 7–7.9 | Good. Enjoyable and worthwhile, though some notable flaws remain. |
| 6–6.9 | Mixed. Clear strengths, but meaningful problems limit the overall experience. |
| 4–5.9 | Weak. The problems outweigh the experience’s stronger parts. |
| 0–3.9 | Poor. Serious problems make it difficult to recommend. |
How to read a score
- Scores run from 0 to 10. Decimals are allowed, and the exact score appears in the review verdict.
- The score is not an average of categories or a reader poll. It summarizes the reviewer’s overall critical judgment.
- Star icons on story cards are rounded to the nearest whole star for quick scanning; they do not replace the exact score.
- Read the verdict and the full review for context. Two games with the same score can have different strengths and drawbacks.